ºÇ½ª¹¹¿·¡§ID:ksUaVJTgbQ 2023ǯ02·î04Æü(ÅÚ) 18:01:42ÍúÎò
ï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤ÎÃæ¤ÇÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤«¡©(±Ñ¸ì¡§If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?)¤È¤Ï¡¢Å¯³ØŪ¤Êµ¿Ìä¤Î¤Ò¤È¤Ä¡£
¤½¤â¤½¤â²»¤Ï¼Âºß¤»¤º¡¢¼ç´ÑŪ¤Ê´¶³Ð¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Ê¤¤¤È¸«¤Ê¤¹¼ç´Ñ¼çµÁ¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨Êý¤Ï¤¢¤ì¤É¡¢°ìÈ̤ˡֲ»¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢¡Ö¶õµ¤¤ä¿å¤Ê¤É¤ÎÇÞ¼ÁÃæ¤ò°ÜÆ°¤·¼ª¤ËÅþ㤷¤¿²»ÇȡפȤ¹¤ë¸«²ò¤¬É¸½à¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
°ìÊý¤Ç¡¢²»ÇȤ¬À¸¤¸¤ë¤Î¤Ï²»¸»¤È¤Ê¤ëʪÂΤ¬¿¶Æ°¤¹¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦°Õ¸«¤â¤¢¤ë¡£Á°¼Ô¤ÏWave-based accound¤äProximal Theory¡¢¸å¼Ô¤ÏSource-based account¤äDistal Theory¤È¸Æ¤Ð¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë*2¡£
²»ÇÈÀâ¤Ç¤Ï¡Ö¿¿¶õÃæ¤Ç¤Ï²»¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¡×¤³¤È¤òº¬µò¤Ë¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤ë¤¬¡¢²»¸»Àâ¤Ç¤Ï¤½¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡Ö¿¿¶õÃæ¤Ç¤â²»¤Ï¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì¤òÃγФ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤¬Ëþ¤¿¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤«¤éʹ¤¯¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡Ê¢ªÊªÂΤ¬¿¶Æ°¤¹¤ì¤Ð²»¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ë¡×¤ÈÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë*3¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢²»ÇÈÀâ¤Ç¤Ï²»¤Î¹â¤µ¤âÂ礤µ¤â²»¿§¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤¾¤ì²»ÇȤμþÇÈ¿ô¤È¿¶Éý¤ÈÇÈ·Á¤È¸«¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò²»¸»Àâ¤Ç¤ÏʪÂΤο¶Æ°¤Ë¤è¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¸«¤Ê¤¹¡£
Í뤬ÌĤ俤Ȥ¤ò¹Í¤¨¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÍëÌĤȤʤ벻ÇȤÏÉîÌó340¥á¡¼¥È¥ë¤Ç¶õµ¤Ãæ¤ò°ÜÆ°¤·¡¢´Ñ»¡¼Ô¤Î¼ª¤ËÅÁ¤ï¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢²»¸»¤È¤Ê¤ëÍ뤫¤é3¥¥í¤Û¤ÉÎ¥¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤È¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¸÷¤Ã¤Æ¤«¤é10É÷ФäÆÍëÌĤ¬Ê¹¤³¤¨¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¡£
²»ÇÈÀâ¤ò¼è¤ë¤Ë¤·¤í²»¸»Àâ¤ò¼è¤ë¤Ë¤·¤í¡¢ÊªÍýŪ¤Ë¤Ï¿¶Æ°¤È¤¤¤¦¸½¾Ý¤È¤·¤Æ°ì½ï¤¯¤¿¤Ë°·¤¨¤ë¤â¤Î¤À¤¬¡¢Å¯³Ø¾å¡¢Â¸ºßÏÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢²»¸»¤È²»ÇȤ¬Î¥¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤È¤³¤í¤ËÂ礤ʰ㤤¤¬¸«½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£º£¤Ë»ê¤ë¤Þ¤ÇµÄÏÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤É¤Á¤é¤¬Àµ¤·¤¤¤«¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤Îǧ¼±ÏÀŪµÄÂê¤Ï²ò·è¤ò¸«¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢ÃγФò¿ÍͤʴÑÅÀ¤«¤éºÆ²ò¼á¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¼è¤Ã³Ý¤ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£
If a tree falls in the forest, and no one hears it, does it make a sound?
Albert: "Of course it does. What kind of silly question is that? Every time I've listened to a tree fall, it made a sound, so I'll guess that other trees falling also make sounds. I don't believe the world changes around when I'm not looking."
Barry: "Wait a minute. If no one hears it, how can it be a sound?"¡ÊDisputing Definitions(lesswrong.com)¤è¤ê¡Ë
¿¹¤ÇÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤È¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤³¤Ë¤Ïï¤â¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤µ¤Æ¡¢¤³¤Î»þ²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡©
Albert: Åö¤¿¤êÁ°¤À¤í¤¦¡¢¤Ê¤ó¤Æ¥Ð¥«¤²¤¿¤³¤È¤òʹ¤¯¤ó¤À¡£»ä¤¬Ê¹¤¤¤¿¸Â¤ê¡¢ÌÚ¤¬Åݤì¤ë¤È·è¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ²»¤òΩ¤Æ¤¿¤Î¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤Û¤«¤ÎÌÚ¤¬Åݤì¤Æ¤â²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤Ï¤º¤À¡£»ä¤¬¸«¤Ê¤¤´Ö¤Ë¡¢À¤³¦¤¬ÊѤï¤ë¤È¤â»×¤¨¤Ê¤¤¡£
Barry: ¤¸¤ã¤¢Ê¹¤¯¤¬¡¢Ã¯¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤Ê¤é¡¢¤É¤¦¤ä¤Ã¤Æ²»¤òΩ¤Æ¤ë¤ó¤À¤¤¡©
¤¤¤«¤Ë¤â¡ÖÌڤϲ»¤òΩ¤Æ¤ÆÅݤì¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡×¤ÈÅú¤¨¤¿¤¯¤Ê¤ë¼ÁÌä¤À¤¬¡¢Å¯³Ø¾å¤Ç¤Ï¡Ö²»¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¡×¤ÈÅú¤¨¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¤Ê¤¼¤Ê¤é¡¢´Ñ»¡¼Ô¤¬¤½¤ì¤ò´Ñ»¡¤¹¤ë¤Þ¤Ç¤¢¤é¤æ¤ë²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Ê¤«¤Ç¡¢¼ÁÌä¤Ç¤Ï´Ñ»¡¼Ô¼«ÂΤ¬¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢²»¤òΩ¤Æ¤º¤ËÅݤ줿¤È¹Í¤¨¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¸À¤¤´¹¤¨¤ì¤Ð¡¢¼õ¤±¼è¤ë¦¤¬¤¤¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð²»¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Ê¤¤¡¢¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¡£¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¡¢ÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢Ã¯¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤»þ¤Ëȯ¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ï²»ÇȤǤ¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¿Í¤¬Ê¹¤¯²»¤È¤ÏÊÌʪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¤â¸À¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£
18À¤µª¤Îů³Ø¼Ô¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥Ð¡¼¥¯¥ê¡¼¤¬Ãø½ñ¡Ö¿ÍÃθ¶ÍýÏÀ¡×¤ÇÄ󼨤·¤Æ¤«¤é¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î*1¡¢º£¤Ë»ê¤ë¤Þ¤ÇµÄÏÀ¤¬¸ò¤ï¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¼ÁÌä¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢1883ǯ´©¹Ô¤ÎThe Chautauquan¤Ë¤â°Ê²¼¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ëµ½Ò¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
1884ǯ´©¹Ô¤ÎScientific American Volume 50 Number 14 p.218 (18)¤Ë¤â»÷¤¿¼ñ»Ý¤Î¼ÁÌ䤬¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤¬¡¢²óÅú¤âThe Chautauquan¤Î¤½¤ì¤ÈÊѤï¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£
ËÁƬ¤Ç°úÍѤ·¤¿Albert¤ÈBarry¤ÎÂÐÏäǤϡ¢¡Ö²»¡×¤ÎÄêµÁ¤¬°ú¤¹ç¤¤¤Ë½Ð¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤¬¡¢¸ß¤¤¤ËÁêÈ¿¤¹¤ëÅú¤¨¤Ëé¤ê¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
Boston College Libraries¤Ç¤Ï¡Ö²»¤È¤¤¤¦¸ÀÍդβò¼á¼¡Âè¡×¤È²óÅú¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¿¶Æ°¤ò½Å»ë¤¹¤ëʪÍý³ØŪ´ÑÅÀ¤Ë´Õ¤ß¤ì¤Ð¡Ö²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¡×¡¢Ä°³Ð·Ð¸³¤ò½Å»ë¤¹¤ëů³ØŪ´ÑÅÀ¤Ë´Õ¤ß¤ì¤Ð¡Ö²»¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£
¸À¤¤´¹¤¨¤ì¤Ð¡¢¼õ¤±¼è¤ë¦¤¬¤¤¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð²»¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Ê¤¤¡¢¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¡£¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¡¢ÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢Ã¯¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤»þ¤Ëȯ¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ï²»ÇȤǤ¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¿Í¤¬Ê¹¤¯²»¤È¤ÏÊÌʪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¤â¸À¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£
18À¤µª¤Îů³Ø¼Ô¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥Ð¡¼¥¯¥ê¡¼¤¬Ãø½ñ¡Ö¿ÍÃθ¶ÍýÏÀ¡×¤ÇÄ󼨤·¤Æ¤«¤é¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î*1¡¢º£¤Ë»ê¤ë¤Þ¤ÇµÄÏÀ¤¬¸ò¤ï¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¼ÁÌä¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢1883ǯ´©¹Ô¤ÎThe Chautauquan¤Ë¤â°Ê²¼¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ëµ½Ò¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
Q. If a tree were to fall on an island where there were no human brings would there be any sound?
A. No. Sound is the sensation excited in the ear when the air or other medium is set in motion.¡ÊThe Chautauquan Volume ·. pp.543-544¤è¤ê¡Ë
Q. ¤â¤·Ã¯¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤Åç¤ÇÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é¡¢²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¡©
A. ¤¤¤¤¤¨¡£²»¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¶õµ¤¤Ê¤É¤ÎÇÞ¼Á¤¬¿¶Æ°¤·¤¿»þ¡¢¼ª¤¬»É·ã¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë´¶³Ð¤Ç¤¹¡£
1884ǯ´©¹Ô¤ÎScientific American Volume 50 Number 14 p.218 (18)¤Ë¤â»÷¤¿¼ñ»Ý¤Î¼ÁÌ䤬¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤¬¡¢²óÅú¤âThe Chautauquan¤Î¤½¤ì¤ÈÊѤï¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£
ËÁƬ¤Ç°úÍѤ·¤¿Albert¤ÈBarry¤ÎÂÐÏäǤϡ¢¡Ö²»¡×¤ÎÄêµÁ¤¬°ú¤¹ç¤¤¤Ë½Ð¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤¬¡¢¸ß¤¤¤ËÁêÈ¿¤¹¤ëÅú¤¨¤Ëé¤ê¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
Albert: "The tree produces acoustic vibrations. By definition, that is a sound."
Barry: "No one hears anything. By definition, that is not a sound."
¡Ê...¡Ë
Albert: "Hah! Definition 2c in Merriam-Webster: 'Sound: Mechanical radiant energy that is transmitted by longitudinal pressure waves in a material medium (as air).'"
Barry: "Hah! Definition 2b in Merriam-Webster: 'Sound: The sensation perceived by the sense of hearing.'"¡ÊDisputing Definitions(lesswrong.com)¤è¤ê¡Ë
Albert: ÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é¼ª¤Ëʹ¤³¤¨¤ë¿¶Æ°¤¬À¸¤Þ¤ì¤ë¡£ÄêµÁ¾å¤³¤ì¤Ï²»¤À¡£
Barry: ʹ¤¤¤¿¿Í¤¬¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤À¤«¤é¡¢ÄêµÁ¾å²»¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
¡ÊÃæά¡Ë
Albert: ¤Û¤¦¡ª¥á¥ê¥¢¥à¡¦¥¦¥§¥Ö¥¹¥¿¡¼¤ÎÄêµÁ 2c¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤¦¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ö²»¡§½ÄÊý¸þ¤Î°µÎÏÇȤ¬¶õµ¤¤Ê¤É¤Îʪ¼ÁŪÇÞÂΤËÅÁ¤ï¤ëµ¡³£ÅªÊü¼Í¥¨¥Í¥ë¥®¡¼¡£¡×
Barry: ¤Û¤¦¡ª¥á¥ê¥¢¥à¡¦¥¦¥§¥Ö¥¹¥¿¡¼¤ÎÄêµÁ 2b¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤¦¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ö²»¡§Ä°³Ð¤ÇÃγФµ¤ì¤ë´¶³Ð¡£¡×
Boston College Libraries¤Ç¤Ï¡Ö²»¤È¤¤¤¦¸ÀÍդβò¼á¼¡Âè¡×¤È²óÅú¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¿¶Æ°¤ò½Å»ë¤¹¤ëʪÍý³ØŪ´ÑÅÀ¤Ë´Õ¤ß¤ì¤Ð¡Ö²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¡×¡¢Ä°³Ð·Ð¸³¤ò½Å»ë¤¹¤ëů³ØŪ´ÑÅÀ¤Ë´Õ¤ß¤ì¤Ð¡Ö²»¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£
¤ª¤È¡Ú²»¡Û
¡¶õµ¤¡¦¿å¤Ê¤É¤Î¿¶Æ°¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÄ°³Ð¤Ë°ú¤µ¯¤³¤µ¤ì¤¿´¶³Ð¤ÎÆâÍÆ¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤½¤Î¸¶°ø¤È¤Ê¤ë¶õµ¤¤Ê¤É¤Î¿¶Æ°¡£²»ÇÈ¡£¿Í´Ö¤Ï¿¶Æ°¿ô20¡Á20000¥Ø¥ë¥Ä¤¯¤é¤¤¤Î²»ÇȤò²»¤È¤·¤Æ´¶¤¸¤ë¡£²»¤ÎÀ¼Á¤Ï¶¯¤µ¡¦¹âÄ㡦²»¿§¤Î»°Í×ÁǤÇɽ¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¡Ö¥é¥¸¥ª¤Î°ì¤¬¤¦¤ë¤µ¤¤¡×¡Ö°ì¤òΩ¤Æ¤ë¤Ê¡×¡ÖÉ÷¤Î°ì¡×¡Ê¥¹¡¼¥Ñ¡¼Âç¼ÎÓ¤è¤ê¡¢°ìÉô°úÍÑ¡Ë
¤½¤â¤½¤â²»¤Ï¼Âºß¤»¤º¡¢¼ç´ÑŪ¤Ê´¶³Ð¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Ê¤¤¤È¸«¤Ê¤¹¼ç´Ñ¼çµÁ¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨Êý¤Ï¤¢¤ì¤É¡¢°ìÈ̤ˡֲ»¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢¡Ö¶õµ¤¤ä¿å¤Ê¤É¤ÎÇÞ¼ÁÃæ¤ò°ÜÆ°¤·¼ª¤ËÅþ㤷¤¿²»ÇȡפȤ¹¤ë¸«²ò¤¬É¸½à¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
°ìÊý¤Ç¡¢²»ÇȤ¬À¸¤¸¤ë¤Î¤Ï²»¸»¤È¤Ê¤ëʪÂΤ¬¿¶Æ°¤¹¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦°Õ¸«¤â¤¢¤ë¡£Á°¼Ô¤ÏWave-based accound¤äProximal Theory¡¢¸å¼Ô¤ÏSource-based account¤äDistal Theory¤È¸Æ¤Ð¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë*2¡£
²»ÇÈÀâ¤Ç¤Ï¡Ö¿¿¶õÃæ¤Ç¤Ï²»¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¡×¤³¤È¤òº¬µò¤Ë¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤ë¤¬¡¢²»¸»Àâ¤Ç¤Ï¤½¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡Ö¿¿¶õÃæ¤Ç¤â²»¤Ï¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì¤òÃγФ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤¬Ëþ¤¿¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤«¤éʹ¤¯¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡Ê¢ªÊªÂΤ¬¿¶Æ°¤¹¤ì¤Ð²»¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ë¡×¤ÈÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë*3¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢²»ÇÈÀâ¤Ç¤Ï²»¤Î¹â¤µ¤âÂ礤µ¤â²»¿§¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤¾¤ì²»ÇȤμþÇÈ¿ô¤È¿¶Éý¤ÈÇÈ·Á¤È¸«¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò²»¸»Àâ¤Ç¤ÏʪÂΤο¶Æ°¤Ë¤è¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¸«¤Ê¤¹¡£
Í뤬ÌĤ俤Ȥ¤ò¹Í¤¨¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÍëÌĤȤʤ벻ÇȤÏÉîÌó340¥á¡¼¥È¥ë¤Ç¶õµ¤Ãæ¤ò°ÜÆ°¤·¡¢´Ñ»¡¼Ô¤Î¼ª¤ËÅÁ¤ï¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢²»¸»¤È¤Ê¤ëÍ뤫¤é3¥¥í¤Û¤ÉÎ¥¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤È¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¸÷¤Ã¤Æ¤«¤é10É÷ФäÆÍëÌĤ¬Ê¹¤³¤¨¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¡£
²»ÇÈÀâ¤ò¼è¤ë¤Ë¤·¤í²»¸»Àâ¤ò¼è¤ë¤Ë¤·¤í¡¢ÊªÍýŪ¤Ë¤Ï¿¶Æ°¤È¤¤¤¦¸½¾Ý¤È¤·¤Æ°ì½ï¤¯¤¿¤Ë°·¤¨¤ë¤â¤Î¤À¤¬¡¢Å¯³Ø¾å¡¢Â¸ºßÏÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢²»¸»¤È²»ÇȤ¬Î¥¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤È¤³¤í¤ËÂ礤ʰ㤤¤¬¸«½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£º£¤Ë»ê¤ë¤Þ¤ÇµÄÏÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤É¤Á¤é¤¬Àµ¤·¤¤¤«¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤Îǧ¼±ÏÀŪµÄÂê¤Ï²ò·è¤ò¸«¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢ÃγФò¿ÍͤʴÑÅÀ¤«¤éºÆ²ò¼á¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¼è¤Ã³Ý¤ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£
- ½÷À¥¢¥¤¥É¥ë¥°¥ë¡¼¥×¤Î¡âME¤¬¡Öï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤Î±ü¤Ç°ìËܤÎÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤«¡©¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¶Ê¤òȯɽ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¥¢¥ë¥Ð¥à¡Ö¤Þ¤Û¤í¤Ð¥¢¥¹¥¿¥ê¥¹¥¯(¥Î¥¤¥ß¡¼È×)¡×¼ýÏ¿¶Ê¡£±Ç²è¡Ö¥¹¥Ñ¥²¥Æ¥£¥³¡¼¥É¡¦¥é¥Ö¡×ÁÞÆþ²Î¡£Î¬¾Î¤Ï*4¡£¥¢¥¤¥É¥ë¥°¥ë¡¼¥×¤Î=LOVE¤Î½ô¶¶º»²Æ¤Ï¥Þ¥¤¥Ê¥Ó¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹¤Î¥¤¥ó¥¿¥Ó¥å¡¼¤Ç¥µ¥Ó¤Î¥Ñ¡¼¥È¤¬Æä˹¥¤¤À¤È̾Á°¤òµó¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
- ï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤ÇÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é¡¢²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡©(NEW VISION)
- ï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤Î±ü¤ÇÌڤϲ»¤â¤Ê¤¯Åݤì¤ë(ºÕ¤±»¶¤Ã¤¿¥×¥é¥¤¥É¤ò½¦¤¤½¸¤á¤Æ)
- ï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤ÇÌÚ¤¬Åݤ줿¤é²»¤Ï¤¹¤ë¤«¡©¡Á²»³ÚÀ©ºî¤Ç¹Í¤¨¤ëǾ²Ê³Ø45(²»³Ú¶µ¼¼±¿±ÄʳƮµ)
- µ¡Ç½¤¹¤ëÁÈ¿¥¤Î¾ò·ï¡Ê3¡Ë¡Á¾ðÊó¤ò´ðÈפȤ·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¸³¤¹¤é½ÐÍè¤Ê¤¤¡Á(¥Æ¥¯¥Î¥Ó¥¸¥ç¥ó¥À¥¤¥¸¥§¥¹¥È)
- ï¤â¤¤¤Ê¤¤¿¹¤ÇÅݤ줿Ìڤϡ¢²»¤ò½Ð¤·¤¿¤«¡©(¥¢¡¼¥Æ¥£¥¨¥ó¥¹³ô¼°²ñ¼Ò(Archived))
- ²¿¤¬Ê¹¤³¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤«°ì²»¤Î¸ºßÏÀ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ°ì(ů³Ø¤Îõµá38, pp.147-160)
- Department of History and Philosophy - What is Philosophy?(Plymouth State University(Archived))
- ²»¤ÎÉԺߤÎÃγÐ(The Japan Association for Philosophy of Science ²Ê³Ø´ðÁÃÏÀ¸¦µæ41(2)) pp.81-91
- ²»¤Î¸ºßÏÀ¡Ö¿¿¶õÃæ¤Ç¤â²»¤ÏÌĤäƤ¤¤ë¤«¡×¤ò½ÐȯÅÀ¤Ë¡¢¡Ö²»¤Î¸ºß¡×¤ò¤á¤°¤ë¤¢¤ì¤³¤ì¡£(togetter)
- Ecologist's Diary with Richard Beason: If a tree falls in the forest and no one hears it... it does make a sound!(Functional Ecologists)
- If a Tree Falls(John Hydrisko)
- OPINION: If a tree falls in a forest and no one...(Northern Ontario Business)
¥¿¥°
¥³¥á¥ó¥È¤ò¤«¤¯